Hotel Filters
Hotels with Hiking Near Magic After Hours
Renaissance New York Times Square Hotel
This pet-friendly urban oasis at Times Square is your perfect NYC launchpad! Unwind in soundproof rooms with plush bedding, or upgrade to suites with private balconies for iconic skyline views. Business travelers love the 24/7 work center, while the bowling alley and spa cater to your downtime. Steps from Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue, you’re at the heart of it all. Whether for work or play, every detail here sparks joy—right down to the golf simulators and laundry services for seamless stays.
The Algonquin Hotel Times Square, Autograph Collection
Nestled in a tranquil Manhattan block, this historic hotel has been charming guests since 1902. The vibrant lobby welcomes you, while the Blue Bar offers exquisite martinis and cocktails inspired by theatre district tales. Perfectly located near Fifth Avenue shopping and the Empire State Building, you’ll even get travel tips from the adorable feline concierge. Whether for business meetings or family trips, amenities like the fitness center and childcare ensure a seamless stay.
Moxy NYC Times Square
In the heart of NYC, this hotel blends creative design with playful spirit, offering affordable yet stylish stays. Its 612 modern rooms, designed by Yabu Pushelberg, feature flexible furniture and high-speed Wi-Fi for today’s travelers. The spacious social hubs are perfect for work or leisure. Dine at Bar Moxy’s lounge or Magic Hour—NYC’s largest year-round rooftop bar with breathtaking skyline views. With TAO Group’s culinary spots and Blind Barber’s grooming services, it’s a vibrant choice for business or fun!
Even Hotel New York - Midtown East
The Box House Hotel
Even Hotel New York - Times Square South
Arlo NoMad
Le Méridien New York, Central Park
Franklin Guesthouse
Doubletree by Hilton New York Times Square West
Courtyard New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue
Pod Brooklyn
Pod Times Square
Frequently Asked Questions
Everything you need to know about Magic After Hours
The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue is a top choice, just a 7-minute walk from the venue. It offers 24-hour concierge service, luxury accommodations, and some rooms feature views of Central Park. The hotel also includes a private lounge perfect for unwinding before or after the show, ideal for guests seeking comfort and convenience.
The Peninsula New York delivers exceptional accessibility—only a 10-minute walk away. With its exclusive guest services, private check-in lounges, and skyline-view rooftop bar, this hotel enhances your experience. Guests can enjoy premium amenities like personalized itineraries and complimentary welcome refreshments, making it a standout choice for discerning travelers.
Yes, The Ritz-Carlton, New York, Central Park features spacious rooms with floor-to-ceiling windows offering panoramic views of Central Park and the Manhattan skyline. Just a 12-minute walk from the show venue, it also provides private shuttle service to major entertainment districts. Each room boasts smart climate control and premium bedding, ensuring restful nights before and after the magic.
Consider Moxy New York Times Square, known for its vibrant, modern design and social atmosphere. Located just 8 minutes on foot, it features an all-day lounge, themed bars, and interactive lobby spaces. Its youthful vibe and 24-hour café make it perfect for post-show gatherings, blending entertainment and comfort seamlessly.
Hilton Garden Inn New York / Midtown East is ideal for families, only 10 minutes from the venue. It offers family suites, free breakfast, and on-site childcare services. Nearby attractions include the New York Public Library and Brooklyn Bridge Park, perfect for family outings. Its clean, safe environment and welcoming staff ensure a stress-free stay.
The Westin New York at Times Square offers 24/7 fitness center access, round-the-clock dining, and late checkout options. Located just 5 minutes from the venue, it features modern rooms with smart controls and instant support systems. Whether you're staying out late or need extra time, this hotel ensures a seamless, comfortable experience.
Traveler Reviews
See what other travelers say about Magic After Hours
Renaissance New York Times Square Hotel
Staying at the Renaissance New York Times Square Hotel was an absolutely fantastic experience! The location is unbeatable—right in the heart of Manhattan, just a short walk from Times Square, Broadway shows, and all the iconic sights. The hotel itself is modern, clean, and well-maintained, with spacious rooms that feel both luxurious and cozy. The bed was incredibly comfortable, making for a restful night’s sleep. Staff were friendly, efficient, and always ready to help. Whether you're visiting for business or leisure, this hotel offers excellent value and a truly memorable stay. I’ll definitely be returning.
The Algonquin Hotel Times Square, Autograph Collection
Staying at The Algonquin Hotel Times Square was an absolute delight. It’s a small, intimate hotel with a unique charm and elegant details that make it stand out. The staff went above and beyond with their friendly and attentive service—always smiling, helpful, and genuinely welcoming. The location is unbeatable: perfectly situated between Times Square and Fifth Avenue, making it easy to explore shopping, dining, and entertainment right outside the door. I loved how walkable everything was, and the convenience of being just steps from subway access. This isn’t just a place to stay—it’s a true NYC experience. Highly recommend for anyone looking for style, comfort, and a central spot in the heart of Manhattan.
Moxy NYC Times Square
Staying at Moxy NYC Times Square was a great experience overall. The rooms are definitely compact—smaller than a closet, which is pretty typical for Manhattan—but that’s just part of the New York reality. What stood out most was how fantastic the whole hotel smelled; it had a fresh, inviting ambiance right from the lobby. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful, always ready to assist with anything. One thing to avoid: the Margarita package offered through the platform felt unnecessary and overpriced—definitely not worth it. Also noticed the elevator touchscreens didn’t respond properly when touched, but that was a minor glitch. Despite those small issues, the location, vibe, and service made up for it. I’d absolutely stay here again if I’m back in NYC.
Even Hotel New York - Midtown East
New York definitely comes with a high price tag—just grabbing a quick bite near the hotel can cost you $30 or more. But Even Hotel New York - Midtown East makes up for it with its unbeatable location. Walking to Times Square or Broadway takes under 15 minutes, and the city lights at night are absolutely stunning. The towering skyscrapers and iconic smokestacks lining the streets give the whole area a unique, energetic vibe. Despite the pricey surroundings, this hotel offers great value and comfort. I was genuinely impressed by the convenience and atmosphere. If I ever return to New York, I’d definitely choose this hotel again.
The Box House Hotel
The Box House Hotel exceeded my expectations in nearly every way—except for the front desk staff, who could have been a bit more welcoming. Everything else was top-notch. The location is fantastic: just a short subway ride from downtown Manhattan, with plenty of great restaurants and shops nearby. My room was clean, spacious, and beautifully designed with modern touches. The bed was incredibly comfortable, and the air felt fresh and crisp throughout the stay. I especially appreciated the well-lit bathroom with strong shower pressure and smart storage solutions. Even though the check-in experience wasn’t as warm as I’d hoped, the overall quality of the hotel, the attention to detail, and the value for money made up for it completely. I’d definitely book here again when visiting New York.
Even Hotel New York - Times Square South
Staying at this hotel was a real highlight of my trip to New York! While the room isn’t large, it’s incredibly well-designed and spotlessly clean—everything feels brand new and thoughtfully maintained. I especially appreciated how quiet it was despite being right in the heart of Times Square South; it truly offers a peaceful retreat from the city buzz. The location is perfect—just steps away from the subway station, making travel around Manhattan super convenient. Whether you’re heading out for dinner, shopping, or catching a show, everything is within easy walking distance. In a city where prices can get steep, this place stands out for offering great value without compromising on comfort or cleanliness. I’d definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a smart, central base in NYC.
Arlo NoMad
The Arlo NoMad is an excellent choice for a stay in New York City. The view from the room is fantastic, and while the space isn’t huge, it’s well-designed and perfect for two travelers. What really stood out was the incredible value for money—this place offers luxury-level comfort at a surprisingly affordable rate. The room was spotlessly clean, with attention to detail that made the stay feel truly special. Friendly staff, convenient location near major attractions, and a modern vibe throughout. I’d definitely book again and recommend this hotel to anyone visiting NYC.
Le Méridien New York, Central Park
I always come back to this hotel whenever I visit New York—it’s become my go-to choice for a perfect stay. The location is unbeatable: just a short walk from Central Park, with plenty of restaurants, shops, and attractions nearby. The room was clean, spacious, and well-appointed, and the staff went above and beyond to make me feel welcome. From check-in to checkout, everything felt seamless and personalized. It’s not just a hotel—it’s a comfortable home away from home. Highly recommend for travelers who value convenience, quality, and a touch of elegance.
Franklin Guesthouse
Staying at Franklin Guesthouse was an absolute delight! The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming, and I appreciated the option to check in early (for a small fee), which made our arrival so much smoother. The room was spotlessly clean, and the neighborhood felt safe and quiet—perfect for a relaxing getaway. What really stood out was how convenient the location is: just steps away from a cozy corner market where we picked up snacks and essentials. Everything we needed was within walking distance, including public transit that made exploring New York City a breeze. Honestly, I’d have given every category a perfect 5-star rating if it weren’t for the app glitching and automatically unchecking my selections. Despite that minor frustration, this place exceeded my expectations—great value, warm atmosphere, and a homey feel. Definitely planning to return.
Doubletree by Hilton New York Times Square West
Staying at the Doubletree by Hilton New York Times Square West was an absolute highlight of my trip! The front desk staff were incredibly welcoming and friendly—despite booking through a third-party platform, I still received all the Hilton Honors benefits including a room upgrade, bonus points, and complimentary drinks and snacks. That’s seriously impressive value. The hotel is perfectly located on a bustling street full of other hotels, just steps away from the main action in Times Square. Even late at night (after 10 PM), there were plenty of people around, and while I did see some unhoused individuals during the day, I never saw anything concerning—no scary encounters or safety issues. Overall, it felt secure and well-connected. One small note: there’s a nearby spice shop downstairs with strong aromas, but honestly, you get used to the bold flavors everywhere in NYC. It didn’t affect my stay at all. If you’re visiting New York, this hotel is definitely worth considering for its great location, excellent service, and fantastic perks.
Courtyard New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue
The hotel is incredibly convenient, just a short walk from the main train station—perfect for an early morning departure to the airport. Located right on the main street, it's easy to spot and navigate to. The room was spotlessly clean, spacious for a city stay, and very comfortable. The bed was cozy, the bathroom had all the essentials with strong water pressure, and the overall ambiance was quiet and welcoming. Great value for money, and I’d definitely stay here again if I’m back in New York. Highly recommend for travelers looking for a reliable, central base.
Pod Brooklyn
The Pod Brooklyn is my top choice whenever I visit NYC. Located just steps from the L train, I can be in Manhattan in under 5 minutes—perfect for exploring the city quickly. Situated on Bedford Avenue, the area is packed with amazing local spots, from cozy cafes to trendy bars and restaurants. The hotel itself is sleek, clean, and well-designed, offering a smart balance of comfort and efficiency. Even though the rooms are compact, everything is thoughtfully laid out. It’s a fantastic value for the location and quality. I’ve stayed here multiple times and will definitely come back—this is where I now book every time.
Other Destinations You Might Like
Explore more amazing destinations