The Catbird Seat

Sayville landmark hotels background

Sayville/The Catbird Seat Top Hotel Picks

Select your travel dates to find the best prices and availability

Hotel, Destination
Check-in
--
Check-out
--
Rooms & Guests
1 Room, 1 Adults
Scroll down to see more
Hotel Filters

3<3

4.84.64.0

HikingLuggage StorageFishingPoolPet FriendlyWedding Banquet ServicesBarPicnic AreaSurfingParkingGolf CourseSnorkelingMedical RoomBeach Volleyball

Top Hotels Near The Catbird Seat

Featured
Best Price
Top Reviewed
Star Rating
#HotelStarsRatingReviewsDistance
1Come As You Are Inn LLC★★★4.8-0.35 km
2The Madison Fire Island Pines★★★4-7.98 km
3Grove Hotel★★4.6-8.5 km
Come As You Are Inn LLC

Come As You Are Inn LLC

4.8 / 5Outstanding
59 Greene Ave
0.35KM from The Catbird Seat
Picnic AreaBarHikingLuggage StorageFishingSnorkeling
per night
From
USD**4
The Madison Fire Island Pines

The Madison Fire Island Pines

4 / 5Good
22 Atlantic Walk
7.98KM from The Catbird Seat
Wedding Banquet ServicesPet FriendlyPool
per night
From
USD**6
Grove Hotel

Grove Hotel

4.6 / 5Great
1 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove
8.5KM from The Catbird Seat
Wedding Banquet ServicesBarLuggage StorageFishingBeach VolleyballMedical Room
per night
From
USD**5

Other Destinations You Might Like

Explore more amazing destinations

Defined BeaudeeSaint Lawrence the Martyr Roman Catholic ChurchPolished Skin Care Lounge & Nail BarRES Home CareGeneration KiaMerrell InstituteUnited Church PreschoolBrookside County ParkJohn Pearl Elementary SchoolSayville High SchoolBohemia Shopping PlazaSayville Falls Mini GolfAdelphi College Suffolk DivisionSpider Bite Beer CoSt. John's Lutheran ChurchSouth Bay ArtsSkincare By WendySAMMI SPAChildren's Playground - Rubber Mat Ground - No sand or bark chipsConnetquot Public LibraryGillette ParkBrowse 'n' Buy Mail Order MarketCaptain KayakCherry Avenue Dog ParkSayville LibraryThe Crushed OliveBowlero SayvilleUS Veterans Affairs DepartmentPearle VisionBohemia Recreation CenterPremier EstheticsSayville PlazaSans Souci County ParkIslip Grange ParkSavage Classical GuitarSayville Marina ParkOld NavySparrow ParkThe Common Ground at Rotary ParkMinisterios Alfa & Omega Long Island NY.
3 Best Hotels Near The Catbird Seat, Sayville (2026) | HopeGoo